What's the difference between an in-home and GPS medical alert device?

Choosing between an in-home and GPS medical alert device is the most common decision Canadian seniors and their families face. Here's a clear breakdown of the differences.

In-Home Medical Alert Systems consist of two parts: a base station (plugged into your wall) and a wearable button (pendant or wristband). When you press the button, it communicates with the base station, which then connects to the monitoring centre. These systems work within approximately 300 metres of the base - covering a typical home and yard comfortably.

Advantages of in-home systems: lower monthly cost (starting around $29/month), typically better audio quality through the base station speakerphone, and no need to charge a wearable device daily. The button itself often lasts years on a single battery.

Limitations of in-home systems: they don't work outside the range of the base station. If you fall in a parking lot, at a neighbour's house, or anywhere away from home, the device won't connect.

GPS Medical Alert Devices are all-in-one wearables with a built-in cellular radio, GPS chip, and speaker/microphone. They work anywhere in Canada that has cellular coverage - at home, at the store, at a park, or while travelling.

Advantages of GPS devices: they work everywhere, and most allow family members to check your location in real time through a companion app. Some models also include fall detection.

Limitations of GPS devices: they require daily or every-other-day charging (like a smartphone), cost slightly more ($39-$55/month), and the audio quality may not be as clear as a dedicated base station.

The right choice depends entirely on the senior's lifestyle. Many families choose an in-home system for a parent who is mostly homebound and a GPS device for one who is more active.